• Marketplace
  • Resources
  • Business Directory
  • Events
  • Advertise
  • Brand Pulse
  • Publish a Press Release
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Contact
  • About Us
The FUTURE OF WORK® since 2003
Allwork.Space
No Result
View All Result
Subscribe
  • More
    • Columnists
      • Dr. Gleb Tsipursky – The Office Whisperer
      • Nirit Cohen – WorkFutures
      • Angela Howard – Culture Expert
      • Drew Jones – Design & Innovation
      • Jonathan Price – CRE & Flex Expert
    • Get the Newsletter
    • Events
    • Advertise With Us
    • Publish a Press Release
    • Brand PulseNew
    • Partner Portal
  • Latest News
  • Business
  • Leadership
  • Work-life
  • Career Growth
  • Tech
  • Design
  • Workforce
  • Coworking
  • CRE
  • Podcast
  • More
    • Columnists
      • Dr. Gleb Tsipursky – The Office Whisperer
      • Nirit Cohen – WorkFutures
      • Angela Howard – Culture Expert
      • Drew Jones – Design & Innovation
      • Jonathan Price – CRE & Flex Expert
    • Get the Newsletter
    • Events
    • Advertise With Us
    • Publish a Press Release
    • Brand PulseNew
    • Partner Portal
  • Latest News
  • Business
  • Leadership
  • Work-life
  • Career Growth
  • Tech
  • Design
  • Workforce
  • Coworking
  • CRE
  • Podcast
No Result
View All Result
Subscribe
Allwork.Space
No Result
View All Result
Advertisements
Kube Suite - TL
Home CRE

Empty Offices, Soaring Debt, Nervous Investors — Exactly How Much Trouble Are Banks In Amid CRE Market Turmoil?

Financial institutions are facing a $5-Trillion question: Will today's record-high office vacancies cause banking collapse?

Jonathan PricebyJonathan Price
February 16, 2024
in CRE
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
Empty Offices, Soaring Debt, Nervous Investors — Exactly How Much Trouble Are Banks In Amid CRE Market Turmoil?

Bank investors and short sellers have started to take notice of the risks of banks with large CRE portfolios and are trying to spot those under the most stress as office vacancy rates in America have reached 20%.

  • U.S. banks face increasing risks as CRE loan maturities loom and clash with record-high office vacancy rates amid changing work patterns.
  • Banks are reacting by slowing CRE lending, bolstering loan loss reserves, and cautiously selling off debt portfolios.
  • Global CRE markets, while stressed, are less critical outside the U.S., with banks overall better prepared than in previous real estate downturns.

Banks in the U.S. have nearly $5 trillion of commercial real estate loans on their books. At the same time, office vacancy rates in America have reached 20% — breaking the record last set in 1990. This is not a comfortable situation for the banks, because the landlord companies owning such empty or half-empty buildings will not be able to service those CRE loans for long. 

Bank investors and short sellers have started to take notice of the risks of banks with large CRE portfolios and are trying to spot those under the most stress. An early target was Aozora Bank, a mid-sized Japanese bank with a large U.S. loan portfolio, whose shares fell a third in two days in late January as rumors swirled about its bad debt level. Chairmen of other banks are looking nervously at their share price as the market opens each morning in case their bank is the next in the firing line. 

Advertisements
Maximize Flexible Space Revenue

Why so many vacancies? 

When the last record was set in 1990/91, the cause of the record-high vacancy rate was a recession in the U.S. and in other countries, including the U.K. — suppressing the demand for office space. That is not the case today, with U.S. economic performance breaking all sorts of positive records, even if the current administration gets no credit for it. Today’s empty offices are rather attributable to a longer-term shift in working patterns, with companies questioning whether they really need a desk for every worker, at the same time as those workers are questioning whether they really want to commute to work on America’s congested highways. 

Not all offices are equally affected by this drop in demand. The market seems to be bifurcating into prime, new buildings, with good energy ratings and excellent facilities on the one hand, and everything else on the other. Take-up of the new stock is still holding up reasonably well, whereas the secondary, grade B or C space is finding no takers. Office workers are, it seems, becoming very picky about where they toil, and employers are having to offer high-quality space to attract them into work. 

Advertisements
Yardi Kube automates flex and coworking operations

The other distinction that seemed to apply, at least up to the end of last year, was location. Location has always been the prime determinant of real estate value, of course, but since the Covid pandemic, it is the city center prime locations — traditionally the best places to own — that suffered the most from weak demand, whereas the previously unloved suburban locations proved more resilient. Commuting a couple of miles into the local town center seems more acceptable than an hour’s drive into the city. However, the latest reports indicate a slackening of demand for suburban centers as well, at least for conventional lettings if not for flexible space, so it may be just a delayed reaction. 

A looming loan crisis

For landlords, the fall in demand for office space is exacerbated by the fact that virtually all of the loans they took out to buy buildings will experience significant increases in cost when they come up for refinancing, because of the rise in interest rates since they were first drawn down. Many CRE loans are due to mature in the next three years with Trepp, a firm that tracks real estate trends, putting the figure at $2.2 trillion. Some have described this as a “wall” of debt maturities. 

Banks are therefore anticipating a major deterioration of credit quality on their CRE portfolios with up to a quarter of loans already classified as “criticized.” If they cannot look to an economic upturn to solve the problem this time around, what can they do? 

Some steps that have already been taken are a slowdown in new lending for CRE, and attempts to sell off existing portfolios of debt. Goldman Sachs is reported to have shrunk its CRE loan portfolio by 10% in 2023, though this still leaves it with $26 billion. For a disposal strategy to work there must of course be buyers willing to take on the loans, and the evidence so far has not been encouraging, with relatively few transactions having closed. Those portfolios that have been sold have been described as either “trophies or trash.” That is to say, high-quality buildings that are in good demand from occupiers, or those which are so awful that banks want to get rid of them, whatever the cost. 

Advertisements
Nexudus - Tech Stack Lovers

The second step that most banks have taken is to increase loan loss reserves to provide some room to write off loans without causing capital adequacy problems. A number of U.S. banks have reported increasing reserves on CRE portfolios above 10% and this seems to be the current view in general. Increasing reserves is only feasible if a bank is profitable overall, but as commented earlier, the strong economy has made this possible. 

So, what is the outlook for banks? Will losses on CRE cause any banks to fail? What does the situation look like outside the U.S.? 

Can banks avoid collapse? 

The good news is that banks are in better shape generally today than they were the last time there was a crisis in real estate. Loan-to-Value percentages, that is to say how much of the building’s value was lent by the bank, are much lower than during the last crisis. Some of the banks at least, learnt their lesson from that time and have kept their LTV at a more conservative 60%, leaving more room for a building to lose value without causing a default. 

As already noted, the banks’ loan loss reserve position is in general better than it was, as is the banks’ deposit position, and they are less reliant than they were on funding from the capital market. This is important because customer deposits are more reliable than wholesale funding, as banks discovered in the global financial crisis.

More stories for you

Burberry Slashes 20% of Workforce as Tariffs Tear Into Profits

Burberry Slashes 20% of Workforce as Tariffs Tear Into Profits

2 days ago
Klarna Cuts 40% Of Jobs As AI Starts Relacing Human Roles

Klarna Cuts 40% Of Jobs As AI Starts Replacing Human Roles

3 days ago
Nissan Axes 11,000 More Jobs As Automotive Industry Remains Stuck In Reverse

Nissan Axes 11,000 More Jobs As Automotive Industry Remains Stuck In Reverse

3 days ago
From Cells To Startups Will Former Prisons Be The Next Hot Coworking Spaces

From Cells To Startups: Will Former Prisons Be The Next Hot Coworking Spaces?

4 days ago

Banks also claim to have been originating loans more carefully than they did in the first decade of this century and that, as a result, their loan portfolio is better quality than it was at that time. Even assuming this is true, if demand for space continues to fall, with occupiers not renewing, or taking less space, and landlords being unable to refinance loan maturities at prevailing higher rates, or defaulting because buildings cannot be let, the knock-on effect on banks will start to be visible by 2025 at the latest. 

Outside the U.S. the situation is similar but less acute. Taking the U.K. as the most similar European market to the U.S., vacancy rates are also rising here, but are still little more than half those in the U.S. — with the key London market reporting a vacancy rate around 12%, up from 9% a year ago. British workers have been a lot less reluctant to return to the office than Americans, perhaps because British homes are, on average, much smaller than American ones, making WFH a less attractive proposition.  

The same bifurcation between new, high-quality space and older, less efficient space is also visible in the U.K., with new, attractive buildings still finding takers relatively easily at good rents. This distinction is sharpened in the U.K. by legal requirements for energy efficiency that will mean that buildings rated below a prescribed minimum level will either require substantial remedial investment over the next few years or in the worst cases, may have to be demolished. 

According to Knight Frank, one of the U.K.’s largest realtors, lateral thinking is required for the owners of older buildings, which may include conversion of such buildings into flexible, serviced space. There are numerous examples in the City of London of older buildings, particularly early 20th century buildings, that have found a new lease of life as coworking centers and are generating good cash flow for owners and lenders. 

Advertisements
Disaster Avoidance Experts

The world of work is in transition at present, we just don’t know exactly what it is transiting to. Some elements of the future are clear, however, and they include a strong preference among big users for new, high-quality, green space. That could spell trouble for owners of grade B space, but some help is at hand, as coworking companies are increasingly taking such buildings and repurposing them as serviced space — because another element of the future is the continued long-term growth of flexible, serviced space, where the quality of the service is as important as the space. 

As for banks, the positives are that they can see what is going to happen in CRE so it will not come as a surprise; loan loss reserves are being strengthened in anticipation and loan portfolios are said to be better quality than they were before. 

Nevertheless, it would perhaps be over-optimistic to imagine that no bank will be caught out by the change in working patterns. When the tide goes out, you can see who’s not wearing any trunks.

Advertisements
Subscribe to the Future of Work Newsletter
Tags: BusinessCREInvestment
Share38Tweet24Share7
Jonathan Price

Jonathan Price

Jonathan is a Chartered Fellow of the Chartered Institute for Securities & Investment and was responsible for the world’s first ever public fund for investment in coworking space. Today he acts as a specialist consultant, is a visiting professor at a leading French business school, and is Treasurer of the Flexible Space Association in the U.K.

Other Stories Recommended For You

Burberry Slashes 20% of Workforce as Tariffs Tear Into Profits
News

Burberry Slashes 20% of Workforce as Tariffs Tear Into Profits

byAllwork.Space News Team
2 days ago

Luxury fashion brand Burberry is preparing to cut up to 1,700 jobs worldwide as it contends with declining profits and...

Read more
Klarna Cuts 40% Of Jobs As AI Starts Relacing Human Roles

Klarna Cuts 40% Of Jobs As AI Starts Replacing Human Roles

3 days ago
Nissan Axes 11,000 More Jobs As Automotive Industry Remains Stuck In Reverse

Nissan Axes 11,000 More Jobs As Automotive Industry Remains Stuck In Reverse

3 days ago
From Cells To Startups Will Former Prisons Be The Next Hot Coworking Spaces

From Cells To Startups: Will Former Prisons Be The Next Hot Coworking Spaces?

4 days ago
Advertisements
Maximize Flexible Space Revenue
Advertisements
Disaster Avoidance Experts

Unlock your competitive edge in tomorrow's workplace.

Join a community of forward-thinking professionals who get exclusive access to the latest news, trends, and innovations that are shaping the future of work.

©2024 Allwork.Space News Corporation. All Rights Reserved.

Exploring the Future Of Work® since 2003.

Advertise   Newsletters   Privacy Policy   Terms Of Use   About Us   Contact   Submit a Press Release   Brand Pulse   Podcast   Events   

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Topics
    • Business
    • Leadership
    • Work-life
    • Workforce
    • Career Growth
    • Design
    • Tech
    • Coworking
    • Marketing
    • CRE
  • Podcast
  • Events
  • About Us
  • Solutions
    • Advertise | Media Kit
    • Publish a Press Release
    • Brand Pulse
Subscribe

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
-
00:00
00:00

Queue

      Update Required Flash plugin
      -
      00:00
      00:00